Do Calming Supplements Really Work for Horses?
Walk any show aisle and you’ll see jars promising a “quiet” horse overnight. Some riders swear by them; others see no change at all. The truth sits between marketing hype and hard science. Whether a calming supplement works depends on three factors: the ingredient’s proven mode of action, the individual horse’s diet and stress load, and the product’s bioavailability.
What the Research Says
Magnesium is the only macro-mineral consistently linked to calmer behavior in controlled trials. A WALTHAM study showed oral magnesium slowed reaction-time responses, indicating a genuine sedative effect in excitable horses. The Horse More recent reviews note that many horses simply don’t meet daily magnesium requirements through forage alone, so supplementation corrects a diet gap first and foremost. The Horse
L-Tryptophan, an amino acid precursor to serotonin, looks promising on paper but real-world results are mixed. Two independent trials supplying six grams daily found no measurable drop in heart rate or reactive behavior compared with controls. Mad Barn Canada
Valerian root can produce mild tranquillizing effects, yet doses must build over days before noticeable change and the plant is banned by most competition bodies, including FEI and USEF. The Horse
CBD and hemp derivatives are gaining popularity, but studies to date focus on pharmacokinetics rather than behavioral endpoints; efficacy and permissible thresholds remain unsettled. The Horse
Across all ingredients, veterinarians emphasize starting with a diet audit, then choosing evidence-based products in consultation with a nutrition professional. The Horse
Why Results Vary from Horse to Horse
-
Baseline Deficiency vs. Surplus – A horse already replete in magnesium is unlikely to change after adding more, whereas a marginally deficient animal may soften within days.
-
Source and Dose – Cheap oxides or low-grade herbs often deliver too little active compound to matter; pharmaceutical-grade forms reach target blood levels faster.
-
Stress Context – Supplements modulate, not eliminate, the “fight-or-flight” reflex. Poor saddle fit, gastric ulcers, or inconsistent handling will blunt any nutritional aid.
Choosing an Effective Product
Look for transparent labels that state elemental magnesium (not just compound weight), publish independent quality testing, and avoid banned botanicals if you compete. Nupafeed’s patented MAH® Magnesium pairs pharmaceutical purity with a carrier proven to cross the gut wall efficiently, giving riders a reliable, competition-safe tool to keep horses focused without dulling athletic spark.
Practical Take-Home
Calming supplements can work—but only when the right horse receives the right nutrient in the right form. Magnesium shows the strongest evidence; other actives range from inconclusive to prohibited. Begin with a diet analysis, address management stressors, then introduce a high-quality magnesium product such as Nupafeed MAH®. Most owners notice a softer eye and steadier ride within the first week, validating that science-backed nutrition still beats wishful thinking.
Ready to test it yourself? Experience the difference with Nupafeed MAH® Magnesium Supplements and help your horse stay cool, clear-minded, and competition-ready.
